Design of Life Update: Birds

Print Article
Posted on March 9, 2017 in Amazing Facts, Birds, Darwin and Evolution, Dinosaurs, Education, Intelligent Design, Media, Philosophy of Science

Illustra Media’s Design of Life documentaries only began to explore the marvels of life. In this entry, we look at more wonders among birds.

Illustra-DOL_trilogy_DVD-coverEggs come in a variety of sizes and shapes, as shown in a rapid-fire series in the Illustra film. In an “Egg Mythbuster” piece, explains why some eggs are pear-shaped. The beautiful spotted eggs of the guillemot, long prized by egg collectors (a practice now banned), are shaped to prevent breakage when other birds lands on the rocks where they build their nests. In a video clip, Professor Tim Birkhead (U of Sheffield) describes guillemot eggs as “one of the most beautiful and extraordinary eggs in the bird world” because of their varieties of colors and markings. “It’s a testament to the powers of natural selection,” he adds, personifying the Stuff Happens Law with creative genius.

Aside from that slip, Birkhead shows spectacular drone shots of the sheer cliffs where the seabirds rear their young. He then tells about the “climmers” of the 19th century. Their goal of collecting unusually-colored guillemot eggs had the effect of making them “citizen scientists” who had learned more about the birds’ biology than professional scientists of the time. His main point, though, is to explain the egg’s shape, which may have “a variety of reasons” behind it. After debunking two popular myths, he gives his favorite hypothesis, which has to do with the strength of the eggshell. It is thickest on the long axis which is the most subject to breakage as the mother incubates it. If another bird crash lands on top of her, the egg will likely survive the blow. This still does not explain the colors and markings. Birkhead’s new book is titled The Most Perfect Thing after a descriptive phrase by Thomas Wentworth Higginson (1823-1911), American abolitionist, who said,

‘I think that, if required on pain of death to name instantly the most perfect thing in the universe, I should risk my fate on a bird’s egg’ — Thomas Wentworth Higginson, 1862

Update 3/10/17: Speaking of guillemots, Science Daily just posted a possible explanation for why guillemot chicks leap hundreds of meters off the cliffs where they were reared into the water before they are ready to fly. Their fathers of the guillemots (also called murres) guide them on this “remarkable leap” that has baffled scientists. Many hours of observation showed that the fathers work very hard providing food for the chicks up on the cliff for up to 5 to 7 weeks. As soon as the chick is able, the father guides it down to the sea where it can learn the art of feeding itself. Scientists “discovered that chicks at sea grew at roughly twice the speed of those at the colony, because the murre fathers no longer needed to fly back and forth to the colony to feed them.” The classic documentary Winged Migration includes a scene of a guillemot chick doing the leap, landing with a splash, to the relief of the exhausted father.

Embryos. In the sequence on a developing chick embryo in the Illustra film, scientists describe the “elaborate dance” that takes place, with molecular machines doing jobs, moving systems, and committing parts of the embryo irreversibly toward their roles in the adult. A new paper in PLoS One describes just one stage in the 21-day period when gut motility (peristalsis) begins— i.e., the muscle contractions that will move food through the digestive tract. They watched the sequence unfold on days 6 through 9.

We found that the emergence of an uninterrupted circular ring of smooth muscle correlated with the appearance of propagative contractile waves, at E6 in the hindgut and midgut, and at E9 in the caecal appendix. We show that peristalsis at these stages is critically dependent on calcium and is not mediated by neurons as gut motility is insensitive to tetrodotoxin and takes place in the hindgut in the absence of neurons.

“Our work sets a baseline for further investigations of motility development in this important animal model,” the four authors say.

Chick embryo, from Flight: The Genius of Birds (Illustra Media)

Chick embryo, from Flight: The Genius of Birds (Illustra Media)

Hummingbirds have a flight stabilization system in their neurons. Current Biology has a paper by M. R. Ibbotson about how it works.

The pretectal visual motion processing area in the hummingbird brain is unlike that in other birds: instead of emphasizing detection of horizontal movements, it codes for motion in all directions through 360°, possibly offering precise visual stability control during hovering.

Interestingly, the Allen’s Hummingbird has a subspecies that migrates and another subspecies that does not. says that birders miscounted the two and came to a wrong conclusion that the hummingbirds were in decline, when actually the non-migrating kind were doing quite well at backyard feeders and parks in southern California. The Allen’s hummingbird was on conservation watchlists because it was thought to live only on the Channel Islands offshore. The Audubon Society’s eBird tool allows citizen birders to record their observations. This allowed Christopher Clark to publish corrected statistics in The Auk , a journal of the American Ornithological Society. He says that Channel Island species colonized southern California urban areas sometime before 1966. reported this story on its news page, with photos of the bird and maps where they were observed.

Collective Motion is performed by many birds, like the starlings shown in Flight. Hummingbirds, too, engage in “group mobbing” to scare off owls and other predators by divebombing them, says Science Daily. Whether this is a form of sexual selection to impress females seems dubious, since it would appear difficult for a female to distinguish a single male in a crowd. Even if she could, will she connect his prowess with fatherhood skills? Instead, it may “teach younger birds to distinguish friend from foe” – a function not necessarily independent of giving the girls a good air show.

Starling murmurations, from Flight: The Genius of Birds (Illustra Media)

Starling murmurations, from Flight: The Genius of Birds (Illustra Media)

Migration is undertaken by many bird species in addition to the Arctic terns shown in Flight. The behavior may play more of a role in the general ecology, though, than thought. says that wintering ducks spread plant seeds from one body of water to another, thereby connecting wetlands to each other. This helps prevent habitat loss and fragmentation of ecological zones, and thus improves biodiversity. Some plant seeds move through the birds’ digestive tracts unharmed; plants, therefore, can use birds as a form of air mail for seed dispersal.

Dinosaur-to-Bird Evolution was “not as straight as thought,” says —as thought by evolutionists, that is. Paleontologist Stephen Brusatte debunks various myths of bird evolution, particularly the idea that one can draw a straight line from a dinosaur to a bird in the fossil record. Put his statements in your philosophy pipe and smoke it; do evolutionists really have a story of bird evolution more firm than mere suggestions that stuff happened?

To truly understand the evolution of flight in dinosaurs, Brusatte suggests, will require the melding of mathematical models used to measure the likelihood of flight in a given fossil species and biomechanical studies (based on engineering) that take more into account than just feathers—some fossils have been found, for example, that appear to more closely resemble bats than birds, with membranes for wings. The breakthrough, he suggests, will be the development of anatomical models of dinosaurs that truly represent the evolutionary history of early birds., i.e. creatures capable of powered flight.

He concludes by suggesting that as research continues, it appears likely that some of the current evidence attributed to flight evolution will be thrown out even as new evidence of true development is added, eventually giving us a true picture of what transpired.

Readers are encouraged to watch the Illustra film Flight: The Genius of Birds for evidence and reasons why biologists should, instead, consider intelligent design. At the end of the film, Paul Nelson says,

Here’s the bottom line. You look at the anatomy of a bird, its behavior, its metabolism, the structure of its feathers, the structure of its muscles and so forth — these are multiple independent points in a complex space, out of which flight emerges. And I think from a biological standpoint, to fly at all requires a cause that is able to visualize a distant functional endpoint, and bring together necessary to achieve that endpoint. Uniquely, and universally in our experience, only intelligence is capable of that kind of causal process.

HummingbirdTim Standish adds,

An engineered system is the product of a mind that anticipated a problem and figured out a multi-step way of addressing that problem. In birds you see exactly that kind of process. I believe intelligent design is the best explanation for avian flight, because it’s the best explanation for every other kind of flight that we see. So why would I suddenly change the rules when I go from a 747 to a pigeon? … They’re engineering marvels. They’re works of art. We know where engineered things come from. We know where works of art come from. So why would we attribute a bird to anything other than intelligence or mind?

Go outside and watch your local birds. Then toss a rock into the air. What would it take to make the rock take off against gravity and fly under its own power?


design-of-lifeConvenient quicksleeve copies of the entire film are available from Illustra’s distributor These can be used as ministry give-aways for friends, family, students, churches, clubs, or anywhere there’s an open mind willing to follow the evidence.



No comments have been left

Leave a Reply