November 18, 2026 | Sarah Buckland-Reynolds

Nature Needs People and Vice Versa

Ecological discoveries from Japan
reveal support for humanity’s
God-given role as stewards.

 

Nature Needs Stewards:
Japan’s Biodiversity Surprise Challenges Malthusian Thinking

by Dr. Sarah Buckland-Reynolds

If you have ever taken a class in ecology, it is likely you may have walked away with the impression that the natural world would be in a better state if human beings were not around to disturb its pristine characteristics. The thought, “Nature would be better off if people simply disappeared” reflects a perspective that traces some of its intellectual roots to Thomas Malthus’s argument that unchecked population growth inevitably strains finite resources, an idea that later influenced many environmental and population-control movements (see 13 Nov 2026).

Despite the popularity of this environmental narrative, there is emerging evidence that is challenging that assumption.

When humans disappear, biodiversity takes a surprising turn (Emma Marris, Nature, 5 November 2026), and a linked editorial titled: Ecosystems depend on people: don’t abandon them (Nature, 4 November 2026), scientists explain how they are increasingly finding cases where the disappearance of traditional human land stewardship actually reduces biodiversity rather than leading to environmental thriving.

In examining case studies including Japan, there is increasing evidence that when rural populations disappear and traditional land-management practices cease, many species’ habitats maintained by generations of human activity including irrigation, grazing, woodland thinning, controlled burning, and traditional farming practices, are also impacted.

This article reflects on these cases in light of the Genesis dominion and stewardship mandates, as a reminder that humans and the environment are not necessarily opponents.

Challenging a Popular Ecological Narrative

The modern ecocentric perspective often treats humanity as fundamentally separate from nature or even as its primary enemy. According to this view, humans are largely a destructive force whose footprint should be minimized wherever possible.

Ironically, the Nature editorial rejects this separation, stating that:

“The idea that humanity is separate from the rest of the planet is deep-rooted, but wrong.”

The editorial further argues that:

“Many landscapes seen by European colonists as ‘wilderness’ were in fact tended by Indigenous people.”

This observation is significant. Much of what we call “natural” landscapes today are actually the result of long histories of human stewardship. Rice paddies, grazing lands, managed forests, woodland clearings, maintained wetlands, and traditional agricultural systems often create ecological niches that support an extraordinary diversity of life.

The article goes on to explore Japan’s traditional satoyama landscapes, where centuries of woodland thinning, rice cultivation, and water management created habitats supporting fireflies, frogs, birds, insects, and plants. When these practices were abandoned because of depopulation, many of those habitats began disappearing.

Apart from the article, research emerging in the past decade has shown the importance of sustainable human stewardship in maintaining ecological balance. This is shown in another article:

Vertebrate biodiversity on indigenous-managed lands in Australia, Brazil, and Canada equals that in protected areas (Schuster et al, Environmental Science and Policy, November 2019). Studies based in Canada, Australia and Brazil concluded that the presence of indigenous peoples on lands was characterized by even higher biodiversity than protected areas where these peoples were not allowed to inhabit, in some cases. In their words:

“Indigenous-managed lands have equal-or-higher biodiversity than protected areas…. We found that Indigenous-managed lands were slightly more vertebrate species rich than existing protected areas in all three countries, and in Brazil and Canada, that they supported more threatened vertebrate species than existing protected areas or randomly selected non-protected areas. Our results suggest that overall, Indigenous-managed lands and existing protected areas host similar levels of vertebrate biodiversity in Brazil, Canada, and Australia.”

With these interesting findings emerging across the globe, by what mechanism is this the case?

What longstanding Malthusian assumptions appear to be violated in these cases?

How Getting Rid of Humans Harms Biodiversity

Going back to Marris’ article in Nature, it highlighted studies where biodiversity declined in areas abandoned by people. These were usually linked with simultaneous disappearance of resources added to the land.

For example, when irrigation systems ceased functioning, amphibians and insects lost breeding habitats; when forests were no longer selectively thinned, canopies closed and habitats changed dramatically; when grazing animals disappeared, species dependent on open grasslands declined. As the article notes, this result “contradicts the common assumption that when people leave, nature always thrives.”

In commenting some of Uchida and Matanle’s work on Japan (published in 2025), researcher Peter Matanle stated the opinion that:

“Leaving it alone isn’t doing anyone any good.”

Similarly, the article notes that studies in parts of Europe found that rural abandonment negatively affected bird communities, especially farmland species. They also found that seminatural grasslands, maintained by grazing livestock and traditional land use, often supported significant biodiversity. In the case of Sweden, such habitats are documented to contain up to forty plant species per square metre and provide habitat for many threatened species. These findings suggest that biodiversity is often linked not merely to the absence of disturbance, but to the presence of appropriate stewardship.

In the Biblical worldview, God created man in his own image, and gave him dominion over creation. AiG Creation Museum (photo by DFC)

Reflecting A Biblical View of Human Ecology

From a Biblical perspective, these findings should not be surprising. Unlike the common depiction in ecological circles, Scripture does not present humans as parasites on the planet; neither does it advocate the exploitation of nature. Instead, it portrays humanity as uniquely created in God’s image and entrusted with responsibility over creation. As Genesis 1:28 records God’s instruction to humanity:

“Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion…”

Likewise, Genesis 2:15 states:

“And the Lord God took the man and put him into the garden of Eden to dress it and to keep it.”

The Hebrew concepts behind these commands involve both cultivation and protection. Humanity was not placed in creation merely as a consumer but as a caretaker. This differs sharply from both environmental exploitation and radical ecocentrism. The Biblical worldview recognizes that humans possess unique value because they bear God’s image. Yet that elevated status comes with obligations, as dominion is in fact stewardship, not destruction. Interestingly, even from a secular perspective, the Nature editorial reached quite a similar conclusion.

This interdependence between humans and nature may also be viewed as reflecting design. Humans were created to interact with, cultivate, and care for the environment, and also depend on themselves on the health of the environment. The complementarity observed between people and certain ecosystems is not accidental but consistent with humanity’s intended role within creation.

The Legacy of Malthusian Thinking

The ‘surprise element’ of these findings also raise questions about assumptions inherited from Thomas Malthus and later incorporated into evolutionary thinking. As is often highlighted in Creation–Evolution Headlines, Malthus argued that human populations grow faster than resources, inevitably producing competition, scarcity, and environmental degradation. His ideas profoundly influenced Charles Darwin, as Darwin himself acknowledged that Malthus’s writings helped shape his understanding of natural selection. This struggle for existence with nature selecting to ultimately reduce gene pools became a foundational concept in evolutionary theory.

In many modern environmental discussions, this influence remains visible. Humans are often portrayed primarily as competitors with nature, consuming limited resources at the expense of other species. However, the emerging evidence challenges these assumptions, showing that people frequently create habitats, maintain biodiversity, manage water systems, support pollinators, preserve landscape heterogeneity, and provide ecological disturbances upon which many species depend. This challenges simplistic stereotypes that treat humans as inherently harmful to ecosystems and suggests that the key issue is not merely human presence but the nature of human activity.

Caretakers of Creation

The recent Nature editorial and news feature provide useful ‘food for thought’ and a powerful reminder that God’s conclusion at the end of creation week was not a mistake. Human beings indeed have a place to take care of all creation and are in turn dependent on nature for thriving. Emerging case studies throughout Japan, Europe, Canada, Australia and other locales globally are now indicating that God’s instructions to Adam to “dress it and keep” the Earth is indeed a necessity for ecosystems to thrive.

The Biblical perspective offers a balance between two extremes: unchecked environmental exploitation and the belief that nature flourishes best in the absence of people. Evidence increasingly suggests that this Malthusian framing presents a false choice between human wellbeing and ecological wellbeing. Scripture instead portrays humans as integral to creation’s flourishing, entrusted with its care rather than standing in opposition to it. Far from being a cosmic accident or ecological mistake, humanity appears uniquely suited for stewardship, a conclusion that aligns closely with the Biblical narrative.


Dr. Sarah Buckland-Reynolds is a Christian, Jamaican, Environmental Science researcher, and journal associate editor. She holds the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Geography from the University of the West Indies (UWI), Mona with high commendation, and a postgraduate specialization in Geomatics at the Universidad del Valle, Cali, Colombia. The quality of her research activity in Environmental Science has been recognized by various awards including the 2024 Editor’s Award from the American Meteorological Society for her reviewing service in the Weather, Climate and Society Journal, the 2023 L’Oreal/UNESCO Women in Science Caribbean Award, the 2023 ICETEX International Experts Exchange Award for study in Colombia. and with her PhD research in drought management also being shortlisted in the top 10 globally for the 2023 Allianz Climate Risk Award by Munich Re Insurance, Germany. Motivated by her faith in God and zeal to positively influence society, Dr. Buckland-Reynolds is also the founder and Principal Director of Chosen to G.L.O.W. Ministries, a Jamaican charitable organization which seeks to amplify the Christian voice in the public sphere and equip more youths to know how to defend their faith.  

(Visited 22 times, 6 visits today)

Leave a Reply